I’m a total sucker for Thanksgiving desserts, and honestly, pie is the whole reason I show up to the table. From classic pumpkin to fun twists like honey and toffee almond, I’ve rounded up 13 ridiculously good recipes that are all surprisingly easy to pull off. Trust me, these are going to be the star of your holiday spread.
1. Butternut Squash Pie
If you’re looking to switch things up from your usual pumpkin routine, this is the one. Butternut squash brings a flavor that’s super similar to pumpkin but somehow feels a little fresher. It’s cozy, creamy, and makes the most amazing Thanksgiving dessert. Pile on some whipped cream or a scoop of ice cream and you’re in business.
2. Honey Pie
This pie’s creamy custard gets its flavor from honey, which makes it wonderfully different but just as delicious as the classics. It’s simple, smooth, and incredibly moreish. I love that honey brings something a little unexpected to the table, and I think you’ll really love it too.
3. Salted Caramel Pumpkin Pie
I am absolutely obsessed with salted caramel, so this pie is basically my dream come true. It’s everything you love about a smooth, perfectly spiced pumpkin pie, but the salted caramel is mixed right into the filling. Every single bite is sweet, salty, and completely irresistible.
4. Spiced Plum Pie
Just look at that color! That alone makes it worthy of a spot on your holiday table. And yes, it’s totally vegan. Plum might not be your first thought for Thanksgiving, but nobody will be able to resist a slice. I love it warm with a scoop of ice cream, but once it cools it gets wonderfully jammy.
5. Apple Cheddar Pie
Hear me out on this one! Apple and cheddar totally work, and you really should give it a try. I’m not talking about tossing a whole block of cheese into the apple filling, I promise. The cheese is worked into the crust with just a little bit mixed in with the apples for that perfect savory sweet balance.
6. Cranberry Orange Custard Pie
I love the classics, but sometimes I just want to put something a little different out there. This pie is packed with tart, fresh cranberries and balanced out by a silky smooth orange custard. It’s bright, beautiful, and bakes right in the shell without any fussy blind-baking.
7. Cinnamon Pie
This one is essentially a cinnamon-spiced cheesecake and it is not messing around. It’s creamy, sweet, and absolutely loaded with cinnamon flavor. If you’ve ever walked into a craft store during the holidays and been hit with that incredible smell, this pie captures that exact moment and turns it into dessert.
8. Lemon Meringue Pie
You might not think of lemon meringue as a Thanksgiving dessert, but I think it’s perfect. In a sea of heavy, rich holiday food, this pie is wonderfully light and zingy. There’s a whole layer of creamy cheesecake hiding in there, plus plenty of gooey meringue on top. Trust me, every bite just gets better.
9. No-Bake German Chocolate Pie
German chocolate cake gets its magic from that moist, dark cake and the unique coconut pecan topping, and this pie delivers the same thing. Between the luxurious ganache filling and that nutty, caramel-y top, it’s beyond decadent. Add a little whipped cream and watch your guests lose their minds.
10. Gingersnap Cranberry Lime Pie
This is definitely not your typical Thanksgiving pie, but honestly, it should be. It’s packed with flavor and it’s absolutely stunning. The crust is a simple mix of gingersnaps, walnuts, butter, and brown sugar that you just press right into the dish. No rolling required, just bake it for a quick 12 to 15 minutes.
11. No-Bake Butterscotch Pie
Okay, this pie is seriously dangerous. You’ve got a Biscoff cookie crust, a dreamy no-bake butterscotch filling, and then brown sugar cinnamon whipped cream on top. One slice is never enough, especially once you add that gorgeous toffee drizzle. And since it’s a no-bake situation, it won’t steal any precious oven space on the big day.
12. Toffee Almond Pie
Pecan pie is always a holiday favorite because of that crunchy top and gooey center. This pie has all those same amazing textures, but the big difference is that it uses almonds instead. The sliced almonds give you this wonderfully crisp texture in every single bite. It’s a fun twist on a classic that I think you’ll go crazy for.
13. Pear and Almond Tart
This might just be the prettiest Thanksgiving pie on the entire list. The almond frangipane paired with tender pears is absolutely incredible, and that apricot glaze makes the whole thing shine. It might not be a classic yet, but I have a feeling it’s going to become a family favorite in no time.